Claire MacLeary – Burnout
Published by Contraband, paperback £8.99. I received a free proof copy from the publisher for review purposes.
Claire MacLeary’s first novel, Cross Purpose – longlisted for the McIlvanney Scottish Crime Book of the Year award in 2017 – introduced us to Maggie Laird and Wilma Harcus with warm humour and sharp writing. As follow-up Burnout begins, the duo have settled into their work as private investigators – but the opening conversation of the novel immediately brings tensions: “I think my husband is trying to kill me,” Sheena Struthers tells Maggie. Maggie feels it’s a case they must take on; Wilma feels it’s a case they shouldn’t go near due to Sheena’s lack of evidence other than “a feeling”.
While the revelations about Harvey Weinstein, the #MeToo movement and the release of gender pay gap figures have put issues of equality in the headlines recently, crime fiction has been quietly examining violence against women, domestic abuse and plain old sexism for a long time, and Burnout is a welcome addition to the conversation. There are plenty of angles covered: Maggie’s dealings with the police see them veer towards patronising at best – and in private, lone woman in the team DC Susan Strachan deals with sexist assumptions about what work she’s suited to and hears all the sneers about “women of a certain age”. Meanwhile, Wilma may be strong-willed, but cracks are beginning to show in her marriage as Ian complains she spends too much time on the PI business. Maggie’s colleague, teacher Ros, has a young child and a controlling husband. And then there’s a husband who has to deal with uncomfortable questions from the police…
MacLeary deftly moves between the women, underlining that domestic abuse and misogyny come in many forms and occur in all parts of society, top to bottom. She also reminds us that both men and women can fear to voice suspicion or even realise there is cause for concern, so used are we all to “the way things have always been” and “oh, well, every marriage has its problems”. As I read I feel anger build on their behalf – and anxiety, as I recognise what they don’t yet see in themselves.
It’s hard not to put two and two together at the half-way point and jump to terrible conclusions about what will happen, but MacLeary takes us down a different path. Ros and Sheena are both determined to take back control of their lives; to find themselves again after the suffocation of self to a marriage. My one quibble with the book is that Ros is dispensed with rather too easily – it’s unlikely her future is plain sailing despite her determination, and this isn’t acknowledged because the focus of the final section is so firmly on Sheena (whose tale has an excellent twist to it).
There is little physical violence and no dead bodies in Burnout; no rushing about with flashing lights and sirens – the pain inflicted is more emotional and psychological. But this darkness of subject matter is leavened with humour, especially from Wilma, and the warmth and comfort of her and Maggie’s relationship – which spreads out to enfold Sheena and Ros in particular – is a welcome antidote to the nastier traits on display. Burnout examines a timely subject, but it’s the depiction of relationships, all with plenty of nuance, that is the main reason to pick up this book. MacLeary’s confidence in her writing and central characters grows with every chapter of Burnout, building on the fine foundation of Cross Purpose. You should make time to get to know Maggie and Wilma.
This review first appeared in The Scotsman newspaper on 14 April, 2018. This is copyright of The Scotsman Publications and is being used in this instance with their kind permission.